A major trial into alleged historic sexual offences in Rochdale has collapsed after almost two months in court, following revelations that members of the jury had been discussing a broadcast about “grooming gangs” in a private WhatsApp group.
The case, heard at Minshull Street Crown Court in Manchester, involved six men accused of multiple historic offences — including rape — against three girls in the town. All six defendants deny the allegations and were part-way through a lengthy trial when the jury was unexpectedly discharged in December 2025.
Strict reporting restrictions initially prevented the reason for the collapse from being made public. But after a successful legal challenge by the Manchester Evening News, the full circumstances can now be revealed.
Juror Raises Alarm Over Group Chat
The trial unravelled when one juror approached the judge to report concerns about a WhatsApp group created by fellow jurors. Within the chat, two members had discussed a television broadcast about grooming gangs — a topic directly related to the case they were judging.
The juror handed his phone to the court, prompting an immediate investigation.
Screenshots showed that one juror acknowledged that watching the programme would be “contrary to the judge’s directions”, while another replied: “I’m going to watch it anyway,” followed by a smiling emoji.
When questioned, both insisted they had not actually watched the broadcast. However, defence lawyers argued that the messages suggested otherwise — and that the jurors had knowingly breached clear instructions not to research the case or related issues.
Defence: ‘Real Concerns’ About Jury Conduct
Defence barristers argued that the integrity of the trial had been compromised, saying it was “clear” from the messages that jurors had accessed — or intended to access — outside material about grooming gangs.
Claire Howell, representing one of the defendants, said there was a “real risk” the jurors would continue to ignore the judge’s directions.
Prosecutors suggested the judge could question the two jurors further, but Judge Matthew Corbett‑Jones rejected that approach, warning it could create even more complications.
Judge: ‘No Course of Action Can Cure the Position’
In a detailed ruling, Judge Corbett‑Jones said that questioning the jurors in open court risked undermining their credibility and damaging the fairness of the process.
He also noted that the juror who had responsibly raised the issue was now in an “untenable” position and could no longer continue on the jury either.
With multiple uncertainties and no clear way to repair the situation, the judge concluded that the only option was to discharge the entire jury.
He said he reached the decision “with considerable regret and disappointment”, adding:
“Whatever course of action I take, unanswered questions remain… no course of action that I can reasonably take can cure the position that now exists because of these multi-layered difficulties.”
Re‑Trial Scheduled for August
The six defendants will now face a full re‑trial later this year.
The men and the charges they deny are:
| Name | Age | Address | Charges Denied |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tahir Rashid | 54 | Hudsons Walk, Rochdale | 12 counts of rape, 3 indecent assaults, 1 assault by penetration |
| Mohammed Saleem | 46 | Shaw Road, Littleborough | 8 counts of rape |
| Sucklane Shah | 46 | Milnrow Road, Rochdale | 2 counts of rape |
| Arshad Mohammed | 55 | Merefield Street, Rochdale | 4 counts of rape, 1 assault by penetration |
| Iftaq Hussain | 45 | Hey Street, Rochdale | 3 counts of rape |
| Amjad Mahmood | 53 | Channing Street, Rochdale | 11 counts of rape, 2 indecency with a child, 2 assaults by penetration, 1 indecent assault |
All defendants remain on bail awaiting the new trial date in August.

